Published November 15, 2005 Kathleen R.
|
Tobacco use is the leading preventable cause of morbidity and mortality in the United States.1 Approximately 440,000 deaths each year are attributed to smoking. It is the most common cause of cancer-related deaths in this country, including deaths from lung cancer, laryngeal cancer, esophageal cancer, oral cancers, and bladder cancer. Tobacco use is also a leading cause of heart disease, stroke, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Research suggests that tobacco use results in over $157 billion in annual health-related costs.2 |
|
DefinitionPrevalencePathophysiologySigns
and
|
|||||
| Nicotine Dependence (or Nicotine Use Disorder), as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition3 (DSM-IV-TR), is characterized by both tolerance and withdrawal symptoms in relation to nicotine use. Nicotine dependence can occur with cigarette smoking, smokeless tobacco use, cigar or pipe use, or prescription medications such as the nicotine replacement transdermal patch or gum. For the purposes of this chapter, the phrases "quitting smoking" will be used to represent complete abstinence from tobacco products, and "success" will be used to represent lifetime abstinence. | ||||||||
Fifty-five percent of Americans have tried smoking. Approximately 22.8% of Americans are current smokers and 30% are exsmokers.4 The rates of smoking in the general US population decreased from nearly 42% in 1965 to just over 25% in 1990, but the rate of decline has slowed markedly since 1990.1,5 Nicotine dependence is more prevalent in persons with other mental disorders. According to DSM-IV-TR, 55% to 90% of those with a mental disorder smoke compared with 22% of the general population. There is a high comorbidity of depression with nicotine dependence.6 Approximately 20% of all Americans meet criteria for nicotine dependence at some point in their lives. Among smokers, 50% to 80% are estimated to meet criteria for nicotine dependence. In the United States, the rates of smoking are decreasing more rapidly for males than for females, although male smokers continue to outnumber female smokers. In 2001, 25.2% of US males and 20.7% of females were smokers.4 The incidence of tobacco use is higher in African Americans, in those with less education, and in those of lower socioeconomic status.7 There appear to be genetic factors that contribute to nicotine dependence; the risk for those with a first-degree relative who smokes is three times that of those in a family of nonsmokers.8 Genes may account for as much as 54% of the variance in failed smoking cessation according to one study.9 Risk factors for development of nicotine dependence include a history of alcohol or drug use disorders, primary psychotic disorders (like schizophrenia) and attention-deficit disorders. In children, depressed mood, poor grades and antisocial behavior correlate with smoking rates, but the effects of modeling by peers and family are also likely to be critical factors.8 Fully 70% of smokers report wanting to quit, and 46% attempt to quit each year.10 Only 5% to 7% of them are abstinent from smoking for an entire year after quitting.6 |
||||||||
From the first use of nicotine, physical effects serve to increase the likelihood of repeated nicotine consumption. Nicotine binds to cholinergic receptors in the central nervous system including the anterior nuclei of the thalamus and the cerebral cortex among other areas. In response to repeated nicotine use, the receptors rapidly desensitize and increase in numbers, and both these phenomena conspire to increase the addictive power of nicotine. Dopaminergic neurons within the nucleus accumbens (a brain structure associated with rewards and reinforcement) are activated by projections from nicotine-stimulated neurons. Cell bodies in the ventral tegmental area (a structure associated with perception and modulation of pleasure) are stimulated directly by nicotine and these neurons project directly to the nucleus accumbens(NAcc). Nicotine also causes the release of serotonin, beta endorphins, vasopressin, and glutamate. Nonnicotine components of tobacco smoke inhibit the enzymes monoamine oxidase type A (MAOA) and type B (MAOB), further increasing neurotransmitter expression. As a result of the widespread neuronal activation, nicotine users experience pleasure, reduced fatigue, increased information-processing ability, reduced anxiety, and other reinforcing effects. Tolerance develops as the frequency and dose of nicotine use increases. Increasingly desensitized cholinergic receptors on neurons projecting to the NAcc are quickly produced (up-regulated) to compensate for the actions of nicotine on the brain. The release of dopamine in the NAcc falls as these desensitized neurons fail to produce the necessary baseline stimulation without the presence of sufficient concentrations of nicotine. Withdrawal symptoms occur when the concentration of nicotine fails to mailtain stimulation of the ventral tegmental area and the NAcc. These effects are mediated by increases in noradrenergic outflow from the locus coeruleus and other areas.
Withdrawal effects occur in about half of smokers trying to quit.8 Smoking increases the metabolism of several medications. The effect does not appear to be attributable to nicotine, but rather to a number of other chemicals present in tobacco smoke. By inducing the cytochrome 1A2 hepatic metabolism pathway, the blood levels of the following medications may be lower than expected:
Conversely, the blood levels of these medications may increase when smoking cessation is attempted. While the pharmacologic effects of nicotine and the other components of tobacco smoke very clearly affect the structures in the brain associated with substance dependence, the behavioral aspects of habitual smoking must not be underestimated. Smokers develop strong associations between smoking and other activitieseg, taking breaks at work, eating, and sexual activity. These associations are stored in neural memory circuits associated with emotional memory (amygdala), reward (nucleus accumbens) and determining priority/importance of elements of one's surroundings (orbitofrontal cortex and cingulate gyrus).11 Resisting the cravings associated with activation of these pathways is often the greatest challenge smokers face when attempting to quit. |
||||||||
The first step in treating nicotine dependence is identifying tobacco users. Clinical guidelines for tobacco dependence treatment suggest asking patients systematically at each visit whether they use tobacco.12 This question should be part of an expanded vital signs assessment or in a computer reminder system that is part of the electronic medical record. There is strong evidence that documenting smoking status at every visit increases clinician recognition of nicotine dependence and intervention.12 The criteria for diagnosis of nicotine dependence follow those for other forms of substance dependence.3 According to the DSM-IV-TR criteria for diagnosis of nicotine dependence, the user must demonstrate at least three of the following criteria occurring at the same time during a 12-month period:
In addition, smoking may create negative interactions among family members. Once a diagnosis of nicotine dependence is made, it is useful to characterize the degree to which the patient is physically dependent on smoking. Tthe Fagerstrom Test for Nicotine Dependence(FTND)13 (Table 2), can be very helpful in determining whether nicotine replacement will be necessary and to what degree. The six-question FTND deals with total tobacco intake and craving severity. However, two of the six questions are weighted to comprise a large portion of a patient's total score. These are:
In fact, if a patient reports that the total number of cigarettes is greater than thirty and the time after arising before the first morning cigarette is less than five minutes, he or she can be classified as (at least) "highly" nicotine dependent without further questioning. |
||||||||
Psychosocial Interventions and Pharmacologic Options: Brief Interventions for a Primary Care Setting At the primary care level, national guidelines recommend brief interventions.12 Interventions as short as 3 minutes may substantially increase cessation rates. One common brief intervention designed for health care providers is the "5 A" method, which involves: (1) asking about tobacco status at each visit, (2) advising all tobacco users to quit, (3) assessing the patient's willingness to quit, (4) assisting the patient in quitting, and (5) arranging for follow-up contact (Table 3). Follow-up contact may consist of a brief visit or phone call 2-3 days after quit date.14
Providers can assess a patient's readiness to quit using the transtheoretical model of behavior change.15 If the patient has not thought about quitting, they are in the Precontemplation stage. At this stage, the provider can use motivational interviewing skills to help increase readiness for change14 (Table 5). When applying motivational interventions, it is important to meet the patient at the patient's level of readiness to be most effective. The goal for a patient who is in "precontemplation" for example, is to start to think about quitting, not quit after the current visit. Health care providers can use the "5 Rs" (Table 5) to help enhance a patient's motivation to quit: (1) discuss why quitting is personally relevant; (2) identify potential risks associated with smoking; (3) identify potential rewards and benefits related to quitting; (4) identify potential barriers or roadblocks that might impede the quitting process; and (5) repeat motivational interventions at each visit. There is some evidence that smoking reduction advice along with offering nicotine replacement and/or buproprion (Zyban) may be an effective strategy for smokers initially unwilling to quit.16,17 However, in general, patients at this stage are unlikely to benefit from advice-giving as much as a non-threatening discussion of what is keeping them from quitting at this time.
If the patient is considering quitting but not in the next few months, the patient is in the Contemplation stage. The above motivational interventions along with encouragement and education are likely to be beneficial for patients at this stage. Patients who have made plans to quit are in the Preparation stage. These are the patients who will most benefit from brief interventions. There are some brief techniques that a provider can use to help patients quit:
Patients in the Action stage (those in the process of quitting) are also likely to benefit from the above brief interventions. Relapse prevention is important for patients in the Maintenance stage (those who have quit smoking). Providers at this stage can educate individuals in issues important in preventing relapse, such as being aware of the potential impact of stressful events. In patients who have never smoked, providing reinforcement and encouraging continued abstinence can be effective strategies for prevention. In patients who have relapsed, it is important to deflect guilt and self-doubt with reminders about the frequency of relapse and the need for a renewed commitment to abstinence. Consistently working with patients on smoking cessation increases the chances of success. Intensive Behavioral Interventions Intensive counseling and behavioral therapies for smoking cessation may contain the following elements:
Intensive programs help patients cope with nicotine withdrawal through a number of behavioral strategies. Patients benefit from social support within a group-discussing withdrawal can help the patient cope with the emotional effects. Many intensive programs also offer cognitive strategies to cope with withdrawal such as developing coping phrases (eg, "One day at a time"). Intensive programs may offer training in relaxation strategies, such as diaphragmatic breathing, which can counteract both physical and emotional withdrawal symptoms. Pharmacological Interventions Nicotine replacement therapies (NRTs) include transdermal nicotine patches, gums, nasal spray, lozenges, and inhalers. Both transdermal nicotine patches and nicotine gum are available without prescription. Nicotine replacement options work by delivering nicotine into the body to ease withdrawal while allowing the smoker to break the behavioral habits associated with the cigarette itself. The fact that half of all quitters report withdrawal symptoms makes clear the value in reducing or eliminating the likelihood that these symptoms will impair a quitter's ability to remain abstinent. The advantages of NRT include rapid onset of action, a wide variety of delivery mechanisms, and a step-down approach that allows the patient to gradually decrease nicotine intake over time and minimize withdrawal symptoms. NRT has potential disadvantages as well. Patients can become dependent on nicotine replacement systems (although the likelihood of this is low).19 In addition, it is possible for patients to focus too much of their smoking cessation program on nicotine replacement, while neglecting social and behavioral reinforcers of their addiction. As a result, when the NRT is discontinued they find themselves unable to tolerate cravings cued by behaviors, places and even sensations (eg, encountering the aroma of tobacco in a place he/she associated with smoking or finding a forgotten favorite lighter). Because of these behavioral and cognitive aspects of nicotine addiction, behavioral counseling (either brief or intensive) is an important adjunct to any pharmacological intervention for smoking cessation. Nicotine Gum and Patch Nicotine patches have the advantage of a delivery system that maintains nicotine levels throughout a longer period than any other system. Patches are designed to deliver nicotine transdermally over a 16- or 24-hour period. The most common side effects are rash and insomnia. Switching from 24-hour to 16-hour release systems can often solve sleep problems associated with longer-release patches. Patients usually use patches at a steady dose daily for 6-12 weeks, then taper slowly over an additional 6-12 weeks. Patients may combine the sustained-release properties of a nicotine patch with the rapid-absorption effects of nicotine gum during high-risk situations. This approach may increase abstinence rates by 5-10%.8 Nicotine Nasal Sprays, Iinhalers and Llozenges Bupropion hydrochloride (Zyban) "The recommended and maximum dose of Zyban is 300 mg/day, given as 150 mg twice daily. Dosing should begin at 150 mg/day given every day for the first 3 days, followed by a dose increase for most patients to the recommended usual dose of 300 mg/day" Doses should be separated by at least eight hours between successive doses, and each dose should be taken whole (not crushed, divided or chewed). Therapy is begun before the patient's predetermined smoking quit date. It takes about seven days for steady-state blood levels of buproprion to be attained, so the quit date is typically 1-2 weeks after Zyban is initiated. Treatment should be continued for twelve weeks. The most commonly reported side effects are insomnia, bronchitis, dry mouth, and numbness. Its use is contraindicated in those with a seizure disorder, those with anorexia/bulimia, or those who have used a monoamine oxidase inhibitor (eg, selegiline (Eldepryl), tranylcypromine (Parnate), or phenelzine (Nardil)) within the previous 14 days. Some research suggests that the combination of nicotine replacement and bupropion may have additional benefits in quitting.16 Health care providers interested in prescribing Zyban should thoroughly review the manufacturer's product information before deciding to initiate therapy. Nortriptyline (Pamelor), a tricyclic antidepressant, has also been studied as a potential aid in helping smokers quit.20 While some studies suggest nortriptyline may be equally effective as buproprion SR, the poorer tolerability and increased rate of adverse cardiovascular effects have limited the practical utility of this agent. Nortriptyline is not an FDA-approved treatment for nicotine dependence. In patients for whom buproprion SR is contraindicated, though, nortriptyline may be considered. In the Cleveland Clinic Foundation’s Smash the Ash program, we tend to recommend buproprion and the nicotine replacement patch (along with behavioral counseling) above other pharmacological treatments because of their utility for managing withdrawal symptoms while dissociating the links of nicotine with other habits and behaviors. Addressing Weight Gain Concerns To help alleviate weight gain concerns, providers can discuss healthy replacement strategies for nicotine including drinking water, exercising and eating healthy foods such as raw fruits and vegetables. Many patients also benefit from a discussion of the benefits of quitting smoking versus the risks of the small amount of actual weight gain. Emphasizing that quitting has other appearance-related benefits including reduced wrinkles, increased skin quality, and whiter teeth may also motivate patients who are conscious of their self-image. Alternative Therapies |
||||||||
Several factors appear to affect rates of abstinence in different groups. Women have less success quitting smoking and higher rates of relapse.6 Patients with higher levels of nicotine dependence (as evidenced by higher FTND scores) and those with a history of depression also suffer lower abstinence rates.6 African-Americans and Chinese-Americans appear to metabolize nicotine more slowly than Euro-Americans and this may be related to lower smoking cessation numbers in these groups as compared to Euro-Americans.7 The primary care provider should consider referring patients in these groups to a more intensive smoking cessation program and adding nicotine replacement or buproprion SR (or both) to increase the likelihood of successful abstinence. Buproprion and nicotine gum have been shown to not only double the rate of abstinence; in addition, both interventions appear to attenuate cessation-related weight gain.21 Unfortunately, these benefits may wane after the therapy is discontinued. It is therefore important to use this time to encourage patients to establish other healthy habits such as diet and exercise. Meta-analysis of multiple research studies suggests that intensive counseling programs significantly increase cessation rates.20 Research suggests that "more is better," with more frequent counseling leading to better cessation rates.27 In 2006, the American Psychiatric Association is expected to release its updated practice guidelines for substance use disorders, including nicotine dependence. This document will discuss recent scientific and product developments, and should help us in helping our patient abstain from this very harmful and costly behavior. |
||||||||
|



