Table 4:
Clinical and Laboratory Features of Chronic Beryllium Disease (CBD) and Sarcoidosis
Feature
Chronic Beryllium Disease
Sarcoidosis
Occupational exposure to beryllium
Yes
No
Onset
Acute or insidious
Acute or insidious
Respiratory symptoms
Predominant organ affected
Predominant organ affected
Erythyma nodosum
No
Yes
Dermatitis
Yes
No
Cardiac
Rare
Common

Pulmonary
physiology

Gas exchange abnormalities common; obstruction early, mixed obstruction/restriction or pure restriction late
Gas exchange abnormalities common; restriction, obstruction, or mixed pattern
Bilateral hilar adenopathy
Uncommon
Common
Infiltrates
Diffuse nodular or linear opacities, can be absent
Nodular and/or linear opacities, may be more focal than in CBD
Computed
tomography
Small nodules, septal lines, ground-glass appearance, adenopathy
Small nodules, septal lines, adenopathy
Beryllium lymphocyte
proliferation test
Positive
Negative
Granulomas
Yes, noncaseating granuloma
Yes, noncaseating granuloma
Other
histology
Diffuse mononuclear cell infiltrate common, bronchial submucosa
involved occasionally
Diffuse mononuclear cell infiltrate
common, bronchial submucosa
involved occasionally
Beryllium in tissues
Yes
No
Skin tests      
 -   Tuberculin
Negative
Negative
 -   Kveim
Negative
Positive
 -   Beryllium patch
Positive
Negative
Elevated serum angiotensin-converting enzyme
Uncommon
Common
Response to
steroid therapy
Often stabilizes disease, may improve pulmonary physiology and symptoms, usually requires continuous therapy
Often stabilizes disease that has not spontaneously remitted, may require continuous therapy
Prognosis
Variable, cor pulmonale and progressive fibrosis in some patients, more benign in others
Good prognosis for approximately 80%, may progress to end-stage fibrosis and cor pulmonale.
  
Copyright 2004 The Cleveland Clinic Foundation

Return to Occupational Lung Diseases Chapter