![]() |
||||||||
|
||||||||
| Motto:
"Man must want to achieve more than he is able to achieve...If we do
not reach for the impossible, we shall never reach far enough to discover
the possible. Our wishes should be boundless." -- Dr. Gerhard Domagk, 1947 Nobel Prize in Medicine for the discovery of the first antimicrobial drug |
||||||||
|
Over the last 100 years, tuberculosis (TB) has killed more than 100 million people1, and this has continued unaffected over the last half-century, in spite of the existence of effective anti-tuberculous drugs. This chapter summarizes the current status of the epidemiology, pathogenesis, diagnosis, treatment and control of pulmonary tuberculosis. For purpose of this discussion, we have excluded in the present chapter nontuberculous mycobacterial diseases and other forms of extrapulmonary disease, except pleural TB. |
||||||||
|
||||||||
|
TB
Worldwide TB
in the USA |
||||||||
| Tuberculosis is caused by a group of five closely related species, which form the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex: M. tuberculosis, M. bovis, M. africanum, M. microti, and M. canettii. M. tuberculosis (Koch's bacillus) is responsible for the vast majority of TB cases in the United States. The main defining characteristic of the genus Mycobacterium is the property called 'acid-fastness', which is the ability to withstand decolorization with an acid-alcohol mixture after staining with carbolfuchsin or auramine-rhodamine. Mycobacteria are primarily intracellular pathogens, have slow growth rates, are obligate aerobes, and produce in normal hosts a granulomatous reaction. In cultures, M. tuberculosis does not produce significant amounts of pigment, has a buff-colored, smooth surface appearance, and biochemically produces niacin. These characteristics are useful in differentiating M. tuberculosis from nontuberculous mycobacteria. One characteristic but not distinctive morphologic property of M. tuberculosis is the tendency to form cords or dense clusters of bacilli aligned in parallel. The biochemical background of cording is called 'cord factor' (a trehalose dimycolate), and its contribution to bacterial virulence is still unclear. | ||||||||
|
TB transmission occurs almost exclusively from human to human; a pre-requisite is having contact with a source case. More than 80% of new TB cases result from exposure to sputum smear-positive cases, although smear-negative, culture-positive cases can be responsible for up to 17% new cases.5 In the USA the most important risk factors for development of TB are: immigration from or travel to an endemic area, close contact with a TB case, exposure to untreated cases in congregate living facilities, advanced age, inner-city population, and host immunodeficiency. Tuberculosis is spread by airborne droplet nuclei, which are 1-5 µm particles containing 1 to 400 bacilli each. They are expelled in the air with coughing, sneezing, singing, laughing, talking etc and remain suspended in the air for many hours. They can be inhaled and subsequently entrapped in the distal airways and alveoli. There, bacilli are ingested by local macrophages, multiply within the cells, and within 2 weeks are transported through the lymphatics to establish secondary sites (lymphohematogenous spread). The development of an immune response, heralded by a delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction over the next 4 weeks leads to granuloma formation, with subsequent decrease in the number of bacilli. Some of them remain viable or 'dormant' for many years. This stage is called latent TB infection (LTBI), which is generally an asymptomatic, radiologically undetected process in humans. Sometimes a primary complex (Ghon complex) can be seen radiographically, mostly in the lower and middle lobes, and comprises the primary lesion, hilar lymphadenopathy plus/minus a lymphangitic track. Later on, the primary lesion tends to become calcified, and can be identified on the chest radiographs for decades. Most commonly, a positive tuberculin test remains the only proof of LTBI, and therefore does not signify active disease. Under certain conditions of immature or disregulated immunity, alveolar macrophages and the subsequent biologic cascade could fail in limiting the mycobacterial proliferation, leading to primary progressive tuberculosis (mostly in children less than 5 years old, HIV positive or profoundly immunosuppressed individuals). Factors known to influence this unfavorable course are: patients' age, nutritional status, host immunity, and bacterial infective load. Once infected with M. tuberculosis, 3-5% of immunocompetent individuals will develop active disease eg, secondary progressive tuberculosis within 2 years, and an additional 3-5% later on during their lifetime. So, overall, there is a lifetime risk of reactivation of 10%, with half of it occurring during the first 2 years after infection,6 hence the necessity to treat all tuberculin skin test converters. A recent analysis7 showed that the lifetime reactivation rate is around 20% for most persons with PPD induration more than 10 mm and either HIV infection or evidence of old, healed tuberculosis, and is between 10 and 20% for recent PPD skin test converters, adults younger than 35 years of age with an induration more than 15 mm, or on therapy with Infliximab (a TNFa receptor blocker), and for children younger than 5 years of age and skin induration more than 10 mm. Studies performed in New York City and San Francisco, utilizing DNA fingerprinting indicate that recent transmission (exogenous re-infection), especially among HIV patients, could account for up to 40% of new TB cases. This is significantly different from older studies, which showed that around 90% of new TB cases are the result of endogenous reactivation.8,9 After inhalation, the pathogenic bacilli start to replicate slowly and continuously and lead to development of a cellular immunity in about 4-6 weeks. T lymphocytes and local (pulmonary and lymphatic node) macrophages represent key-players in limiting further spread of the bacilli in the host's organism. This can be seen at the pathological level, where the bacilli are in the center of necrotizing (caseating) and non-necrotizing (non-caseating) granulomas, surrounded by lymphocytes and macrophages. The infected macrophages release interleukin 12, and 18, which stimulate CD4-positive T lymphocytes to secrete IFN-γ (interferon-gamma), which, in turn, activate the macrophage phagocytosis of M. tuberculosis and the release of TNF-α (tumor necrosis factor-alpha). TNF-α has an important role in the granuloma formation, and the control of infection. Genetic defects illustrated by different polymorphisms of the following genes: NRAMP-1 (natural resistance-associated macrophage protein-1), vitamin D receptors, and interleukin-1 have also been shown to be involved in TB pathogenesis.10 It is often difficult to differentiate between genetic predisposition and overwhelming bacteriological load, as often seen in countries with high prevalence of TB. HIV co-infection is the greatest risk factor for progression to active disease in adults. The 'partnership' between HIV and TB has augmented the deadly potentials of each disease. Other risk factors are: diabetes mellitus, renal failure, co-existent malignancies, malnutrition, silicosis, immunosuppressive therapies (including steroids and anti-TNF drugs), and TNF-α receptor, TNF-γ receptor, or IL-12 ß1 receptor defects. |
||||||||
|
A high index of suspicion is needed in countries with high prevalence of infection, though the bacteriological confirmation is required whenever possible. Persistent cough for more than 2-4 weeks should raise the possibility of pulmonary TB. Other common associated symptoms are: hemoptysis, dyspnea, malaise, weight loss, night sweats and chest pain. The symptoms are less pronounced in children, and any exposure to an active TB patient or a positive tuberculin test should raise more concerns about this disease. Table 1 shows the CDC recommendations for clinical and laboratory criteria of TB diagnosis. One inexpensive and rapid diagnostic test is the sputum smear, done by Ziehl-Neelsen (ZN), Kinyoun, or fluorochrome staining methods. ZN stain identifies 50-80% of culture-positive TB cases, and is a very useful diagnostic and epidemiological tool, since smear-positive TB cases are more infectious than smear-negative patients, and have a higher fatality rate. Nevertheless, smear-negative cases may account for up to 20% of M. tuberculosis transmission. In countries with high prevalence of TB, a positive smear signifies TB in 95% of the cases. The lower limit of detection of ZN stain is 5X103 organisms/mL, while rhodamine-auramine fluorochrome staining tends to be more sensitive. In children, M. tuberculosis can be recovered from gastric aspirates, with yields varying from 30%-50% in older children to 70% in infants for 3 consecutive specimens. The role of induced sputum or bronchoscopy in diagnosing TB is well established in patients unable to provide good-quality sputum specimens. Culture media most often used for diagnosis are:
The speciation can be done with biochemical tests, or DNA probes. Direct specimen polymerase chain reaction is a rapid test (1-2 days), though can lead to false-positive results, and has been disappointing in its practicality. Radiographic findings suggesting TB include upper-lobe infiltrates, cavitary lesions, and hilar or paratracheal lymphadenopathy. In many patients with primary progressive disease and in HIV patients, radiographic findings can be very subtle, and include lower lobe opacities and/or miliary pattern. In a study done on HIV-infected pulmonary TB patients, 8% of cases had normal chest radiographs.11 |
||||||||
|
Major Principles
General Recommendations
Therapeutic
Regimens For the culture-positive pulmonary tuberculosis caused by drug-susceptible organisms, there are 4 acceptable regimens:12
For smear-negative, culture-negative TB cases ('clinical TB') a 4-month HR regimen (4HR7 or 2) is acceptable. The doses used in TB regimens are as shown in Table 2. Drug
Resistance Primary resistance occurs in patients with active TB who never received anti-tuberculous drugs Secondary (or acquired) resistance is the occurrence of resistance after mutant's selection or facilitation in the presence of various anti-tuberculous drugs. A cavitary TB lesion may contain up to 109 bacilli in a perfect culture-type aerobic environment. M. tuberculosis has low rates of spontaneous chromosomial mutations, in the range of 1:106 for INH, 1:108 for RIF and around 1:1014 for both agents. These rates are clinically insignificant, unless sub-optimal time intervals or doses of anti-TB drugs facilitate the resistant subpopulations' growth Multi-drug resistant TB (MDRTB) is defined as the presence of at least 1% of Mycobacterium strains in a bacterial population or culture that are resistant to at least INH and RIF. The practices associated with the occurrence of MDRTB are: failure to predict, identify or adequately address non-adherence to therapy, use of an inadequate initial regimen, use of INH monotherapy when the patient actually has active disease (not LTBI), and the addition of a single drug to a failing regimen. The most important demographic clues for drug resistance are: being a resident of a large urban, coastal or border community area (in the USA), or from areas of high MDRTB (outside the USA, eg, Russia), or being HIV-infected (probably reflecting higher proportion of disease resulting from recent transmission). The most important historical clues are prior therapy for TB, and (less so) cavitary lesions. MDRTB is treated with 4 drugs as in usual therapeutic regimens, plus at least additional 2 drugs to which the patient's organism is thought to be susceptible. In patients with culture-confirmed MDRTB, treatment with at least 3 drugs the organism is susceptible to, for at least 12 months after the sputum conversion. Most experts recommend 18 to 24 months total duration of therapy. INH-resistant cases can be treated with RIF, PZA and ETB for 6-9 months, while patients with RIF-resistant TB are treated with INH, PZA and ETB for 9-12 months after sputum cultures become negative. Consultation with a TB expert and Public Health Department's assistance are mandatory in managing a MDRTB case. |
||||||||
|
Infection control efforts to stem TB outbreaks among inpatients and health care staff are essential, since they represent the proximal contacts for any TB source in that particular setting. Although most cases do not need ultimately hospitalization (eg, an isolated TB pleurisy), patients suspected of having active TB are kept in isolation until they are no longer infectious or until TB is ruled out / three negative sputum specimens are obtained. Isolation rooms should have negative-pressure ventilation, with at least 6 air exchanges per hour. Health care workers who come in contact with these patients should wear N95 masks or PAPRs (powered air-purifying respirators) to avoid inhaling infectious particles while in the room with the patients. The isolation can be discontinued after 10-14 days of therapy if they respond to therapy. Patients can be removed from isolation and discharged home if they are returning to their previous non-congregate residence, where the health department identified no individuals at risk (children less than 2 years of age, immunocompromized patients), and the other plausible exposed individuals are being evaluated for LTBI. The outpatient medications should be given using DOT (directly observed therapy) in order to insure adherence to treatment. The recent decline in the USA is largely due to the implementation and utilization of DOT, which has been shown to improve therapy completion rates and to prevent the emergence of acquired resistance and MDRTB. |
||||||||
|
Latent
TB infection (LTBI) Although the PPD is still the best available way to diagnose TB infection, it is not a perfect test:
ATS/CDC recent statement on LTBI14 establishes the thresholds of PPD indurations for different settings and hosts (Table 3). An increase in induration of greater than 10 mm within a 2-year period indicates conversion, irrespective of age. In low-risk patients for TB infection PPD skin testing is not recommended. ATS/CDC recommends specifically LTBI screening to be applied only for high-risk patients (the concept of 'targeted LTBI screening'). The old terminology of 'INH prophylaxis' applied for treatment of LTBI should be abandoned. Similar to the principle of Mantoux reaction, a whole-blood interferon-y release assay (IGRA®) evaluates the cell-mediated immunity to tuberculin. Although it seems to be less sensitive and less specific, it can differentiate between infection and prior BCG vaccination.15 An enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISPOT®) assay has recently been developed that is relatively sensitive and specific in detecting LTBI, by targeting early-secreted antigenic target (ESAT-6), which is expressed only by M tuberculosis, and not by other Mycobacteria or by BCG.16 Although approved by FDA, the cost-effectiveness and the practicality of the above molecular methods are still unclear. The recommended approach to a patient with LTBI is depicted in Table 4. The new ATS/CDC guidelines14 for LTBI treatment recommend isoniazid (INH) either 5 mg/kg daily to a maximum of 300 mg, or 15 mg/kg twice weekly to a maximum of 900 mg. The duration of therapy recommended is 9 months for all patients (including children); if this cannot be accomplished, 6 months is acceptable. This represents a change in previous recommendations of 6 months of therapy for adults and 12 months for HIV-positive patients. This was based on studies showing that a 9-month course is superior to a 6-month course, and almost as effective as 12 months of therapy. Following concerns about decreased rates of adherence to this length of therapy, studies showed that rifampin (RIF) in doses of 10 mg/kg/day up to a total of 600 mg for 4 months or RIF (alternative: rifabutin, with less interactions with other drugs) with pyrazinamide (PZA) daily for 2 months in HIV-infected individuals are effective alternatives to INH for 9 months. However, as a result of reports of severe hepatic injury following RIF-PZA combination administration in HIV-negative patients, the ATS/CDC revised recommendations, endorsed by Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), state that this combination should not be offered to persons with LTBI anymore.17 The tuberculin skin testing is safe during pregnancy. BCG
Vaccination In USA, it is generally accepted that a positive tuberculin reaction in an adult indicates a true infection with M. tuberculosis, especially if that individual is a close contact of a TB case, from a high-prevalence area, or at high risk of exposure. BCG's lower efficacy in preventing TB compared to INH (as part of LTBI treatment), and the interference with tuberculin skin testing has limited its use in the United States. Tuberculous Pleural Effusion
Tuberculous pleurisy is the most common form of extrapulmonaryTB ; it occurs in 10% of PPD converters. It develops when a subpleural TB focus ruptures into the pleural space, and elicits a significant immune response. This can happen either after the primary phase (up to 6 months post-exposure), or during the secondary phase (endogenous reactivation).18,19 Clinically, it often presents with cough, pleuritic chest pain, dyspnea, low-grade fever, and other non-specific constitutional symptoms. PPD skin test is generally positive in 90% of cases. Radiographically, it is generally unilateral, small to moderate in size, more frequent on the right side, sometimes associated with parenchymal disease (ipsilateral infiltrates). The pleural fluid is serous or serosanguineous (rarely hemorrhagic), exudative, with high protein concentrations (>5 g/dL), low pH (<7.30), moderately depressed glucose levels (< 60 mg/dL), and usually lymphocytic (classically >90% cells). Acid-fast bacilli can be isolated in pleural fluid sediment in less than 5% of cases, and in cultures in up to 70% of cases. The pleural biopsy specimens can increase the diagnostic yield to 20% of the cases (on microscopy) and to 80% of the cases (in cultures). Closed pleural biopsy, with pleural fluid analysis and sputum examination, make the diagnosis of pleural TB in more than 80% cases, while video-assisted surgical biopsy has an even higher diagnostic yield. The sputum can be positive for TB between 4% (in isolated TB pleurisy) and 50% cases (in those with extensive parenchymal infiltrates). A pleural fluid adenosin-deaminase (ADA) >60 U/L may support the diagnosis if rheumatoid arthritis or empyema are unlikely, although this test is not routinely recommended. Even if not treated, the clinical course is toward spontaneous resolution, with minimal pleural scarring. Howether, the reactivation rate is higher for cases with co-existent parenchymal foci (>65% of cases at 5 years). The pleural TB is treated with 4-6HR2 regimens. Steroids may hasten the pleural fluid resorbtion and clinical symptoms' resolution, though they don't seem to prevent scar formation.
Less common than the TB pleurisy, tuberculous empyema represents a chronic, active infection of the pleural space. Its incidence was higher historically in patients who underwent therapeutic pneumothoraces, oleothorax, Lucite ball plombage, or pneumonectomy. It can run its course for decades, with a surprising paucity of clinical symptoms. On the CT scan of the chest the pleural 'peel' is thickened, calcified, sometimes locculated; the pleural mass may be accompanied by an extrapleural mass, which is diagnostic of 'empyema necesitans'. The pleural fluid is generally thick, purulent in appearance, positive on microscopic examination for acid-fast bacilli, and occasionally, other aerobic and anaerobic bacteria (indicating presence of a broncho-pleural fistula). In general, the therapy is surgical with a wide range of possible interventions (from parietal decortication, to thoracoplasty, with or without omentopexy/myoplasty etc). The medical therapy is mandatory in an attempt to sterilize all residual TB foci. TB
and HIV Infection |
||||||||
|
TB:
To Be TB:
Not To Be Even though a constellation of drugs, molecular tools and public health strategies are on the horizon, newer diagnostic tools, a better vaccine and novel therapeutic agents are needed urgently in order to fight better this condition. |
||||||||
This information is provided for general medical education purposes only and is not meant to substitute for the independent medical judgment of a physician relative to diagnostic and treatment options of a specific patient's medical condition. In no event will The Cleveland Clinic Foundation be liable for any decision made or action taken in reliance upon the information provided through this web site. |
||||||||
|
Copyright
2004 The Cleveland Clinic Foundation |