![]() |
|||||||
|
|||||||
|
Cough is a symptom that is experienced by all people at one time or another. In otherwise healthy individuals, self-limited cough may occur as part of local irritation due to a viral rhinitis or respiratory infection. Chronic or persistent cough, with a duration greater than 8 weeks, is a very common presenting symptom in outpatient clinical practice. Although chronic cough is usually not caused by a life-threatening disorder, the frequency of this complaint as a cause for a visit to the physician as well as the patient and family's distress and concern about an underlying cause makes chronic cough an important problem. Because cough is a symptom that is a common pathway for a variety of diverse conditions and because there are no reliable objective monitoring tools for cough, the management of cough is quite variable by physicians. A number of studies suggest that, in addition to a history and physical examination, a systematic diagnostic approach including a chest radiograph (CXR), spirometry, bronchoprovocation study in a pulmonary laboratory, sinus imaging, and esophageal pH monitoring will yield a specific diagnosis in the vast majority of patients (> 95%) with chronic cough.1 However, a common situation that clinicians face is the presence of a cough of unclear cause in the setting of a normal CXR and normal spirometry. Whether these patients should undergo a trial of empiric therapy (either sequential or concurrent) or an aggressive and targeted diagnostic evaluation is often unclear. In clinical practice, it is likely that both these approaches are used in conjunction. It is worthwhile to keep in mind that, for a symptom such as cough, simply excluding certain serious causes may go a long way to reassure the patient as well as the clinician and allow a period of observation. An optimal, cost-effective approach to the management of chronic cough remains controversial. Since chronic cough is rarely progressive, often self-limited, and due to a benign cause in the majority of cases, we recommend a stepwise approach employing empiric therapy targeted at the most common diagnoses, without extensive diagnostic testing (Figure 1). |
|||||||
|
Cough is an important physiologic defense mechanism, a protective reflex to augment the mucociliary clearance of airway secretions. The cough reflex is characterized by the generation of high intrathoracic pressures against a closed glottis, followed by forceful expulsion of air and secretions on glottic opening. Intrathoracic pressures of up to 300 mm Hg and expiratory velocities approaching 500 miles per hour may be achieved.1 Although a typical cough has a characteristic acoustic profile and is universally recognizable, there is no clinical test that can document and confirm the presence of cough. This has hampered progress in the study of cough. The symptom of cough involves a reflex arc originating in peripheral cough receptors. Cough receptors are most concentrated in the epithelium of the upper and lower respiratory tracts, but are also located in the external auditory meatus, tympanic membrane, esophagus, stomach, pericardium, and diaphragm. Receptors are predominantly of two types. Irritant receptors are stimulated by noxious fumes or liquids, while mechanical receptors are activated by physical triggers such as touch, displacement, or stretch. Signals from the receptors are carried by vagal afferents to a medullary cough center, which then triggers cough activation via efferents mediated by the vagal, phrenic, and spinal motor nerves. Cough modulation is partly under the control of cortical stimuli. Therefore, irritation anywhere along the reflex arc by a disease process can cause cough. It is useful to classify cough as acute (less than some arbitrary duration of 3 to 8 weeks) or chronic/persistent. Most of the attention by clinicians is devoted to the chronic/persistent variety, since this is the variety that usually prompts patients to seek medical care. Acute cough usually has a self-limited origin, usually viral rhinitis, which does not require specific therapy. |
|||||||
| Cough is the single most common symptom prompting outpatient medical visits in the United States, accounting for 20 million office visits in 1999 (2.7% of the total number of visits).2 The prevalence of cough depends on smoking status, and has been estimated at 5% to 40%, depending on the group studied. Persistent cough is a common reason for referral to a pulmonologist or an allergist. While cough can cause a variety of anatomic and physiologic complications, 98% of patients in one series listed the suspicion of underlying disease to be one of the major factors prompting them to seek medical attention. The aggregate cost of treatment alone for cough exceeds $1 billion in the United States.1 This is in addition to resources expended for repeated diagnostic studies. | |||||||
|
Most patients seek medical attention because of complications of cough, either psychologic or physical. The most common complications include a feeling that something is wrong (98%), exhaustion (57%), feeling self-conscious (55%), insomnia (45%), lifestyle change (45%), musculoskeletal pain (45%), hoarseness (43%), excessive perspiration (42%), and urinary incontinence (39%).1 A host of other physiologic symptoms occur occasionally, due to the high intrathoracic and intra-abdominal pressures achieved. The most common of these include cough syncope, cardiac dysrhythmias, headache, subconjuctival hemorrhage, inguinal herniation, and gastroesophageal reflux. It is important to elicit which specific cough-related symptoms are bothersome for the patient, as a guide to the pace and scope of diagnostic testing. |
|||||||
|
Acute Cough: Acute cough has been defined as one with a duration of less than 3 weeks at presentation.1 In general, acute cough usually results from respiratory infections, of which the common cold is the most frequent. Some authors have proposed a category of subacute cough, with a duration of 3 to 8 weeks. Postinfectious cough due to irritation of cough receptors accounts for the bulk of these cases. However, there are no case series assessing the relative frequency of causes in either the acute or subacute categories. The most common causes of acute cough are listed in Table 1. In the presence of a compatible history and examination, further diagnostic testing is not usually necessary. The mainstay of treatment includes nonspecific antitussive therapy. Under-recognized causes for acute or subacute cough include pertussis and mycoplasma infection. Rarely, life-threatening illness may present primarily with acute cough. Examples include pulmonary embolus, cardiogenic pulmonary edema, and pneumonia. Chronic Cough: The causes of chronic cough in the general population have not been systematically assessed. Chronic bronchitis, usually due to cigarette smoking, is thought to be the most common overall cause of chronic cough, but most smokers with cough do not seek medical attention. There have been at least nine systematic studies in adults of cough etiology. In the absence of use of angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors, the pathogenic triad of postnasal drainage (or drip) (PND), asthma, and gastroesophageal reflux (GERD) have consistently accounted for 90% to 100% of cases among immunocompetent adults.1,3-6 The same triad is relevant in children and the elderly.1,3 In 18% to 62% of patients, there are two causes, and in up to 42% there are three.4,5,7 Of note, all these studies involved patients referred to pulmonologists or cough clinics; however, it is likely that a similar spectrum of causes accounts for the majority of patients seen by primary care providers. Postnasal
Drainage Physical examination may reveal nasal congestion or discharge, nasal mucosal bogginess, mucous in the oropharynx, or a "cobblestoning" appearance of the oropharyngeal mucosa. The examination findings are nonspecific, however, and may be present in any of the other major causes of chronic cough. Although most patients will have at least one symptom or sign, PND can be clinically silent up to 20% of the time.6 Ultimately, PND is a syndrome without a clear definition, and its role in chronic cough is best proven by a response to therapy. The presence of copious sputum is associated with an increased likelihood of chronic sinusitis, but neither the clinical examination nor historical features reliably differentiate it from other causes of PND.3,7 Among patients with chronic cough, up to 38% have some radiologic sinus abnormality.8 Thus, a finding of sinus mucosal thickening on radiographs has only a 29% to 81% positive predictive value for predicting that chronic sinusitis is responsible for cough.1,8 However, one report documented a 100% positive predictive value for the finding of air-fluid levels on four-view sinus radiographs.8 Asthma The presence of asthma does not reliably implicate it as the cause of chronic cough. The positive predictive value of a suggestive history is only 56%.11 A 20% decrement in FEV1 after methacholine inhalation, while indicative of bronchial hyperresponsiveness, may have a positive predictive value as low as 74% for diagnosing the cause of cough.6 Even detailed analysis of methacholine challenge test characteristics cannot reliably enhance specificity. Thus, proof that asthma is the inciting factor in chronic cough requires demonstration of a response to directed therapy. Gastroesophageal
Reflux In a minority of cases, reflux-mediated irritation of laryngeal receptors or episodic microaspiration underlie GERD-induced cough. However, cough is usually attributable to a reflex loop involving vagal afferents in the distal esophagus, and proximal reflux is unnecessary in the pathogenesis.12 Symptomatic heartburn or water brash occurs in only a minority (25% to 50%) of affected individuals.1 Other historical features, such as exacerbation at night, in the supine position, or after eating, do not reliably differentiate GERD-induced cough from other causes.9 GERD frequently accompanies other causes of cough; up to 80% of asthmatic patients have abnormal 24-hour pH probe findings.1 Recurrent elevations in abdominal pressure may contribute to this phenomenon. A self-perpetuating cycle of cough and GERD may ensue, making identification and treatment of GERD crucial in the integrated management of all cough syndromes. Ambulatory 24-hour esophageal pH monitoring is the most reliable test for GERD. It is important to include a temporal symptom log when conducting pH monitoring in order to document the causality of reflux events vis-à-vis cough. Frequently, close examination will reveal that cough preceded the reflux event. A temporal symptom log may also substantiate GERD as a cause for cough even when pH probe scores lie within the "normal" range. The finding of an abnormal pH probe carries a 90% to 100% sensitivity, but the positive predictive value may be as low as 35% when using therapeutic response as a gold standard.1,13 Angiotensin-converting
Enzyme Inhibitors Eosinophilic
Bronchitis Chronic
Bronchitis Bronchiectasis Postinfectious
Cough Cancer Psychosomatic
Cough Rare Causes of Chronic Cough:
|
|||||||
|
The management of chronic cough typically involves some combination of simple screening studies (CXR and spirogram), additional specific diagnostic studies (methacholine provocation, sinus imaging, or a pH probe), and empiric therapy for the three most common entities (rhinitis, asthma, and GERD) (Figure 1, 2). Patients with chronic persistent cough in whom there are no specific clues by history and examination and who have a normal CXR and spirogram represent the common management dilemma for the clinician. A major decision involves the extent of specific diagnostic testing as opposed to trials of empiric therapy. There is no adequate guidance from randomized clinical trials to help the clinician choose between these two strategies. The approach is usually "negotiated" with the patient, partly based on the level of subjective distress and the level of exasperation felt by the patient as well as the clinician. Pinpointing the cause of chronic cough is often difficult. Cough may be the sole manifestation of disorders such as asthma, GERD or PND, with a paucity of other historical features to suggest the correct diagnosis. Features of cough, such as timing, associated sputum production, and cough character (eg, brassy) are not helpful in distinguishing causes.9 A high proportion of patients have two or more responsible causes. Finally, there are no diagnostic tests with a sufficiently high positive predictive value to reliably implicate any condition as the cause of cough. Thus, diagnosis hinges on demonstration of a response to a specific therapy. Evaluation and treatment using our algorithm (Figure 1, 2) assume that failure to remedy the cough using trials of empiric therapy will precipitate appropriate diagnostic testing. It is important to remember that treatment fails in a significant proportion of nonresponders due to inadequate intensity or duration of treatment. One study found that 14% of referred patients had been correctly diagnosed but treated with insufficient regimens.5 In these cases, diagnostic testing will facilitate appropriate narrowing and intensification of treatment. Since the overwhelming majority of patients will have PND, asthma, or GERD, it is crucial to assiduously investigate the roles of each prior to further investigations. Common causes for diagnostic frustration include:
Although most investigators recommend CXR early in the evaluation of chronic cough, only 4% to 11% of nonsmokers have culpable abnormalities.4,5 The yield of fiberoptic bronchoscopy is similarly low, with only 4% of those with normal CXRs having endobronchial abnormalities. Even with a finding of endobronchial disease, the positive predictive value is only 50% to 89%.1 In assessing for the presence of uncommon causes of chronic cough, chest CT has a relatively higher diagnostic yield and should be performed prior to cardiac tests in the absence of cardiac symptoms. |
|||||||
|
Postnasal
Drainage Asthma The presence of bronchial hyperresponsiveness should be demonstrated by provocation testing or reliable history prior to the use of oral steroids and when bronchodilators alone are ineffective in the presence of high clinical suspicion. Caution is warranted when interpreting the results of empiric therapeutic success with asthma therapy-eosinophilic bronchitis and postinfectious cough may respond similarly. For this reason, we recommend an attempt to taper therapy in patients who have not undergone bronchoprovocation testing. Gastroesophageal
Reflux Ambulatory pH monitoring should be performed when maximal therapy fails. Documentation of persistent symptomatic acid reflux should prompt consideration of esophageal fundoplication. The operative risk and morbidity of fundoplication have diminished considerably in recent years due to the expanding use of laparoscopy. Success rates approaching 85% may be expected for improvement of cough after surgical management.16 Eosinophilic
Bronchitis Chronic
Bronchitis Bronchiectasis Postinfectious
Cough |
|||||||
|
Evaluation of cough depends on a systematic evaluation of potential causes. A recent consensus statement from the American College of Chest Physicians1 outlines a diagnostic and therapeutic protocol for chronic cough. This schema focuses on using diagnostic tests to systematically exclude potential etiologies for cough. The basis for this approach lies in a consideration of the anatomic location of all cough receptors. A particular strength of this algorithm is that it forces clinicians to maintain a comprehensive differential diagnostic perspective during evaluation. Ultimately, however, delineation of the underlying cause (or causes) can be accomplished only by demonstrating a response to therapy. For this reason, we believe that systematic empiricism is an acceptable alternative approach, with serial assessments of treatment response. |
|||||||
This information is provided for general medical education purposes only and is not meant to substitute for the independent medical judgment of a physician relative to diagnostic and treatment options of a specific patient's medical condition. In no event will The Cleveland Clinic Foundation be liable for any decision made or action taken in reliance upon the information provided through this web site. Copyright 2003 The Cleveland Clinic Foundation |